Philadelphia pizza obsessives have a secret they only whisper to friends they really like: one visit to Fishtown’s Circles + Squares can ruin every other slice in town. 🍕
Locals rave that the tiny spot’s hand-tossed 16-inch circles and Detroit-style 10-inch squares hit that magic balance of blistered crust, tangy sauce, and caramelized cheese that keeps them refreshing the online ordering page on Toast week after week.
How This Two-Style Pie Spot Became Philly’s Most Addictive Secret
At Circles + Squares, the obsession started with a simple idea: take two classic forms of pizza and push them both to the edge of perfection.
The shop specializes in thin, hand-tossed round pies and fluffy, Detroit-style squares with crispy, cheese-fringed edges, each one made to order with careful attention to texture and balance. 🍕
The circles arrive with a crisp-but-chewy crust that holds up effortlessly when you lift a slice, a detail fans repeatedly praise on for its “no flop” structure and slight char that adds just enough smokiness to the bite.
Meanwhile, devoted regulars insist the squares are on another level entirely: airy inside like a Sicilian slice, yet ringed with deeply caramelized cheese that crackles at the edges and locks in all that rich sauce and molten cheese in the middle.
Gushing reviews rank these pies as among the very best in Philadelphia’s fiercely competitive pizza scene, with pizza fanatics even breaking them down slice by slice on sites like One Bite and in detailed Philly pizza roundups, which only fuels the spot’s cult-like following and long lines. 🔥
There is a strong “insider club” energy here—pizza nerds talk about Circles + Squares the way sneakerheads talk about limited drops, urging newcomers to try both styles so they can join the ongoing debate over which is the true champion after browsing the full list of pies.
Food Highlights
-
16-Inch Hand-Tossed Circles: Classic thin-crust pies made with hand-tossed dough, highlighted as a “classic thin crust, hand-tossed pizza,” praised for a crisp underside, slight char, and just-chewy-enough crust that holds its shape when lifted.
-
10-Inch Square Pan Pizza: A thicker pan-style pizza on light focaccia dough with crispy cheese edge and sauce on top, adored for the contrast between its airy interior and that addictive caramelized cheese ring.
-
Chicken Parm Square: A 10-inch square pan pizza topped with homemade chicken cutlet, mozzarella, aged provolone, tomato sauce, fresh oregano, grana, and extra virgin olive oil, loved for combining classic comfort flavors with that signature crispy-edged square base. 🍗
-
UNCLE GUTT CIRCLE: A 16-inch hand-tossed circle pizza with pepperoni and fried onions under mozzarella and aged provolone, tomato sauce scattered on top, then finished with fresh oregano, grana, and extra virgin olive oil, making it a must-try for those who want a fully loaded yet balanced pie.
-
Vodka Circle: A 16-inch circle pie topped with dry and fresh mozzarella and housemade vodka sauce, finished with fresh basil and grana, sought after for its creamy, tomato-rich sauce and party-cut slices ideal for sharing. 🍸
-
Cheesesteak: While pizza is the main event, the house-shaved beef and Cooper Sharp cheesesteak on a 10-inch seeded Liscio’s roll, earns love from locals for giving them a legit Philly cheesesteak option alongside their favorite pies.
Atmosphere
Circles + Squares leans into a no-frills, neighborhood takeout vibe, described on their official site as a “neighborhood pizza spot” that keeps the focus squarely on the pies.
Guests typically order online through the Toast page or pop in for pickup, matching the straightforward system explained at the top of the online order portal, which details timing and their no-phone policy.
There is a casual, slightly underground energy, like you’ve unlocked a local secret shared only by devoted pizza fans who hunt down places through apps, maps, and review sites. 😎
It feels less like a sit-down dinner and more like a mission to pick up a legendary pie and race home before that cheese cools, guided by the address pinned on Apple Maps.
Bottom Line
Circles + Squares is a must-visit for pizza lovers chasing elite crust, crispy-edged Detroit-style squares, perfectly balanced circles, and true “top 5 in Philly” bragging rights—all packed into one low-key Fishtown spot. 🍕
Address:
2513 Tulip St, Philadelphia, PA 19125
📞 NO PHONE – follow the instructions on their online ordering page for timing and updates.
🕔 Wed–Thu, 4–8 PM; Fri–Sat, 4–9 PM; Sunday, 12–8 PM (Closed Mon and Tue)