Tulsa’s Andolini’s Pizzeria Cherry Street is the kind of place locals recommend with zero hesitation, then casually “just happen” to tag along.
The energy is lively, the pies are huge, and the attitude is all heart, from the dough to the last drizzle of spicy honey.
If you love serious pizza, cold drinks, and a room that actually feels alive, this Cherry Street icon delivers.
How Andolini’s Pizzeria won locals’ hearts
Andolini’s Pizzeria Cherry Street won locals over by treating pizza like a craft, not a shortcut.
From day one, the focus has been on made‑from‑scratch dough, sauces, and toppings, giving every pie a fresh, honest flavor.
The owners leaned into Tulsa pride, building a spot that feels like a neighborhood gathering place where regulars feel known, not processed.
People come in for big, shareable pies and end up returning for the consistent quality and friendly, down‑to‑earth service.
The menu mixes classic comfort with bold specialty pies, so everyone at the table can find a favorite without overthinking it.
Families, date nights, and friend groups all blend in the same room, which makes the place feel warm and lived‑in instead of stiff.
You’ll hear laughter from the bar, kids negotiating for “one more slice,” and servers moving with a relaxed but dialed‑in rhythm.
That everyday energy, busy but welcoming, makes it easy for locals to turn this into their default pizza answer.
Great pies, easy atmosphere, and a sense that they care about every pan that leaves the oven are what keep Tulsa coming back.
Food Highlights
-
Andolini’s Combination: A fully loaded classic stacked with multiple meats and veggies, this pizza is a crowd‑pleaser and a favorite for groups who want a “no arguing, just share” option that hits all the familiar cravings. 🍕
-
DeMarco of Brooklyn: A love letter to New York–style pie, this pizza leans on high‑quality tomatoes, olive oil, and fresh mozzarella for a simple, rich flavor that appeals to purists and anyone chasing that classic boardwalk‑style slice.
-
Triple Pepperoni Jamfest: Built for pepperoni addicts, this pie layers different styles of pepperoni with serious cheese pull, making it a go‑to order for guests who want something salty, crispy, and unapologetically indulgent.
-
Peppa Pig Specialty Pizza: With its mix of savory meats, creamy cheese, and a kick of sweetness and spice, this playful specialty pie wins over adventurous eaters who like a little heat and contrast in every bite. 🌶️
-
BBQ Chicken Pizza: Smoky cheese, tender chicken, and a bold barbecue profile make this a popular alternative for diners who want a break from red sauce but still want something rich and comforting.
-
Margherita‑Style Cheese Pizza: Simple and focused on the basics, this pie shows off the dough, sauce, and cheese, making it a must‑try if you like to judge a pizzeria by its most stripped‑down slice.
-
Build‑Your‑Own Pie: Many regulars customize their own pizza with toppings like jalapeños, extra meats, or veggies, which lets them turn that core crust and sauce into a personal favorite they order the same way every visit.
Atmosphere
The vibe at Andolini’s Cherry Street is lively and unpretentious, with the buzz of conversations, clinking glasses, and staff moving at a quick but friendly pace.
It feels like a true neighborhood hub, where families, couples, and groups of friends all share the same space without stepping on each other’s vibe.
You get that comfortable mix of casual dining and “night out” energy, making it just as good for a relaxed slice as for a full, linger‑a‑little dinner.
It’s the kind of room that makes you want to stay for one more slice or one more drink.
Bottom Line
Andolini’s Pizzeria Cherry Street delivers big, scratch‑made pies, a laid‑back but lively room, and a menu that actually rewards repeat visits.
If you’re in Tulsa and craving pizza with personality, this spot easily earns a place on your must‑visit list. 🍕
Address: 1552 E 15th St, Tulsa, OK 74120
📞 (918) 505-4850
🕔 Open daily Mon – Thu, Sun 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM | Fri – Sat 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM