Sitting at 15 Newark Way in the heart of Maplewood, Artie’s is a locally-owned pizzeria, bakery, and wine bar rolled into one irresistible package — and it has become one of the most talked-about spots in all of New Jersey’s competitive pizza scene.
Built on a philosophy of seasonal ingredients, locally sourced produce, and handcrafted everything, this neighborhood gem proves that the best pizza doesn’t need gimmicks — just great dough, a ripping-hot wood-fired oven, and a kitchen that genuinely cares.
From housemade pastries in the morning to wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza in the evening, Artie’s has carved out a beautiful niche in Maplewood that feels both elevated and deeply welcoming. 🍷
How Artie’s Won Maplewood’s Hearts
When a wood-fired pizzeria in Maplewood NJ starts drawing comparisons to the best restaurants in New York City, you know something special is going on.
The restaurant, formerly known as Arturo’s Osteria & Pizzeria, built a loyal following over years of consistently exceptional cooking before evolving into what it is today — a sleeker, more focused neighborhood destination that has only gotten better with time.
Every pizza is fired in a wood-burning oven that delivers that unmistakable combination of chewy interior, blistered crust, and just-right char that pizza purists dream about — and that first-timers immediately become addicted to. 🔥
Diners who expected a casual pizza joint walked in and discovered something far more interesting: a place where the seasonal wood-fired pizza menu changes regularly, where the wine list is thoughtfully curated, and where even the bread is housemade — courtesy of their own in-house bakery, The Bread Stand.
A former top pizza destination in New Jersey, Artie’s carried that pedigree forward under its new name — and the locals who have loved this address for years will tell you, without hesitation, that it has never been better.
This is what a neighborhood pizzeria is supposed to be: community-centered, ingredient-driven, and worth every single bite. 🌿
Food Highlights 🍕
-
Santo Pizza: Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, Italian sausage, onion, and chili oil — bold, spicy, and deeply satisfying, with the chili oil tying every element together beautifully. 🌶️
-
Margherita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, crushed tomato, basil, and extra virgin olive oil — the purist’s perfect pie.
-
Bosco Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, locally grown mushrooms, fontina, and parmigiano — a highly recommended white pie.
-
Montagna Pizza: Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano, arugula, and speck — elegant and layered, with the peppery arugula and salty speck. 🥬
-
Bianco Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, extra virgin olive oil, and sea salt — beautifully minimal.
-
Caciocavallo Pizza: Tomato sauce, shaved Sussex County caciocavallo, dried oregano, and extra virgin olive oil — a love letter to old-world Italian pizza tradition. 🧀
-
Maple Bacon Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, heritage bacon, shaved onions, Pennsylvania maple syrup, and parmigiano — the sweet-and-savory wildcard.
Atmosphere
Artie’s radiates the kind of warm, effortlessly cool energy that makes you want to linger over a second glass of wine long after the last slice is gone.
The interior is intimate and thoughtfully designed, with an open kitchen and the intoxicating smell of a wood-fired oven filling the room with a sense of occasion that feels both casual and special at the same time.
“Great vibe on the inside,” one diner summed up simply — and the combination of candlelit tables, natural materials, and a buzzing, community-driven crowd. 🕯️
Bottom Line
🌟 Five reasons to visit Artie’s tonight:
-
Wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas with that perfect char-and-chew balance you can’t find just anywhere
-
Locally sourced, seasonal ingredients in every dish — you taste the difference immediately
-
The Bosco and Margherita pizzas alone are worth the drive from anywhere in the tristate area
-
A rotating seasonal menu that gives loyal regulars a compelling reason to return again and again
-
Bakery, pizzeria, and wine bar in one address — making it perfect for any time of day 🍷🍕
Address:
15 Newark Way, Maplewood, NJ 07040
📞 (973) 762-8600
🕔 Mon–Thu: 8 AM–4 PM & 5–9 PM | Fri–Sat: 8 AM–4 PM & 5–10 PM | Sun: 8 AM–4 PM & 5–9 PM