In the charming coastal state of Maine, two exceptional pizzerias stand out from the crowd: OTTO Pizza in Portland and Zeppa’s Pizza in Ellsworth.
OTTO dazzles with innovative combinations like their legendary Mashed Potato, Bacon & Scallion pie, while Zeppa’s brings authentic New York-style expertise spanning three generations to Maine’s shores.
OTTO Pizza
Pizza lovers searching for innovative pies need to visit OTTO Pizza in Portland, Maine.
This beloved local institution has been serving up creative combinations since 2009 that keep locals and tourists coming back for more.
The thin, perfectly crispy crust provides an ideal canvas for their unique topping combinations that have earned them a devoted following across New England.
Food Highlights
- Mashed Potato, Bacon & Scallion: A legendary combination that put OTTO on the map with its creamy potatoes, crispy bacon and fresh scallions
- Butternut Squash, Ricotta & Cranberry: A sweet and savory white pizza featuring smooth squash, creamy ricotta, and tart dried cranberries
- Three-Cheese Tortellini: An innovative pasta-topped pizza with cheese-filled tortellini on a tomato base
- Buffalo Cauliflower with Blue Cheese: A vegetarian twist on buffalo wings with roasted cauliflower and tangy blue cheese
- Spicy Pulled Pork with Scallion: Tender pulled pork with a kick, balanced by fresh scallions
Atmosphere
The rustic interior features wooden tables and an antique-trimmed bar creating a casual, welcoming vibe.
The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating options.
The space maintains its historic charm while providing a laid-back setting perfect for enjoying innovative pies.
Why It’s One of the Best in Maine
OTTO has mastered the art of combining unexpected ingredients into absolutely delicious pizzas.
Their commitment to quality and creativity has earned them multiple locations across Maine and Massachusetts.
The restaurant’s ability to consistently deliver unique flavor combinations while maintaining the perfect crust makes it a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts.
Address: 225 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101
Zeppa’s Pizza
Pizza lovers searching for an authentic New York slice in Maine need to make their way to Ellsworth.
This family-owned gem brings three generations of New York pizza-making expertise straight to Maine’s coast.
Lisa and Hugh, third-generation restaurant owners from New York, have created a slice of the Big Apple in Downeast Maine, complete with family recipes passed down through generations.
Food Highlights
- Lobster White Pizza: A perfect Maine-meets-New York fusion that locals rave about
- Classic NY Style Pizza: Available by the pie or slice, featuring the perfect chew and excellent sauces
- Hawaiian Pizza: A tropical twist on their classic pie that keeps customers coming back
- Homemade Cannoli: Made from an authentic Italian family recipe passed through generations
- Garlic Knots: Fresh-baked and described by customers as “yummy”
Atmosphere
The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating with a casual, family-friendly vibe.
The interior has the authentic feel of a traditional New York pizzeria, making it perfect for both quick slices and leisurely meals.
The space is welcoming and unpretentious, ideal for families and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Why It’s One of the Best in Maine
Zeppa’s has earned a remarkable 4.9 out of 5 rating from customers, making it one of the highest-rated pizzerias in the region.
The combination of authentic New York-style pizza techniques with Maine ingredients creates an unforgettable dining experience.
The restaurant’s commitment to family recipes and traditional methods ensures every visit delivers consistent, high-quality food.
Address: 92 Water St, Ellsworth, ME 04605