Goodfellas Pizzeria on Mass Ave brings a big-city pizza-counter spirit to one of downtown Indianapolis’ liveliest corridors. 🍕
Its calling card is the enormous, hand-tossed 22-inch pie, made fresh daily and ready by the slice or as a full-table centerpiece.
Behind the pizza case, the Wiseguy Lounge adds a moody cocktail-and-bourbon escape, giving one address two very different reasons to linger. 🥃
How Goodfellas Pizzeria won locals’ hearts
Goodfellas earned attention by committing to a clear promise: New York-style pizza served in seriously oversized fashion.
The restaurant makes its 22-inch pies fresh daily, creating a shareable spectacle that is hard to ignore once it reaches the table. 🍕
A pizza case at the counter lets guests make a quick slice decision without turning lunch, a pre-show stop, or a late-night bite into a long production.
That mix of grab-and-go convenience and made-to-order hand-tossed pies gives Mass Ave diners options for almost any pace of day.
The giant scale is part of the fun, but the format also delivers practical value for groups splitting a pie after exploring downtown.
Locals can make it a simple pizza stop, then discover that the experience continues beyond the counter at the Wiseguy Lounge. 🥃
The lounge’s focus on craft cocktails, rare bourbon, and single-barrel whiskey provides a reason for pizza fans and drink enthusiasts to meet under one roof.
Its Prohibition-inspired personality turns an ordinary slice run into a more theatrical evening, complete with a change of scenery after dinner.
Goodfellas also fits Mass Ave’s social rhythm, sitting close to the Old National Centre and the Athenaeum’s arts and entertainment activity.
That location makes it an easy meeting point before a performance, after an event, or during a spontaneous downtown stroll.
The restaurant presents itself around independent-business culture, family, community, and customer care—values that help a neighborhood place feel personal rather than interchangeable.
Open late on Fridays and Saturdays, it remains available when a classic dinner hour has passed, and the city is still moving.
Most of all, Goodfellas pairs an uncomplicated pleasure—hot New York-style pizza—with an unexpected lounge experience, a combination that keeps a first visit from feeling like the last.
Food Highlights
-
New York-Style 22-Inch Pie: The signature hand-tossed, gigantic pie is made fresh daily and built for sharing; it is the clearest introduction to Goodfellas’ larger-than-life pizza identity. 🍕
-
Pizza by the Slice: Slices displayed in the pizza case make for a fast, flexible order when a whole pie is more commitment than the moment calls for. 🍕
-
Fresh Hand-Tossed Pie: Guests can order a pie made fresh rather than selecting from the case, making this a fitting choice for a group that wants pizza straight from the oven. 🔥
-
Extra-Large Breadstick: This oversized breadstick is finished with garlic butter, Parmesan, and oregano, with a choice of dipping sauce; it is a fitting side for anyone who enjoys the big-format approach. 🥖
-
Calzone: Listed among Goodfellas’ core offerings, the calzone is a convenient folded-pizza alternative for diners looking for a handheld change of pace. 🥟
-
Meatball Sub: This substantial sandwich joins pizza and calzones on the restaurant’s offerings, giving meatball fans a classic Italian-American option beyond a slice. 🥪
-
12-Inch Pie Monday Special: The official site advertises 50% off favorite 12-inch pies, making a smaller pie a particularly appealing way to sample the restaurant’s pizza on the right day. 🍕
Atmosphere
Goodfellas mixes the energy of a New York-style pizza counter with the more secluded, old-school feel of the Wiseguy Lounge. 🍸
Guests can keep things casual with a slice near the front or settle into the lounge for craft cocktails and whiskey.
The contrast is the appeal: quick-service pizza up front, then a more atmospheric place to pause and talk in the back.
Bottom Line
Visit for giant, fresh hand-tossed pizza, quick slices from the counter, oversized breadsticks, a whiskey-and-cocktail lounge, and a Mass Ave location near major downtown entertainment. 🍕🥃
Address: 545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
📞 (317) 602-3401
🕔 Open Sun–Wed, 11 AM–12 AM | Thu, 11 AM–1 AM | Fri–Sat, 11 AM–3 AM