Ok, everyone knows there are hundreds of great Pizza spots all across Colorado.
But Joy Hill in Denver and Antonio’s Real New York Pizza in Estes Park take things to the next level.
From rooftop vibes and sourdough crusts to robot servers and East Coast authenticity, these two spots redefine what it means to grab a slice in the Rockies.
Joy Hill
Joy Hill turns pizza night into an experience—think crackly sourdough crusts, house-made mozzarella, and toppings that zigzag from classic to wildly creative.
This Broadway hotspot fires its pies in a wood oven, blending Colorado’s local flavors with a dash of old-school Italian charm.
With a rooftop patio for sunset slices and a menu that’s equal parts comfort and adventure, it’s no wonder this spot snagged the title of Colorado’s best pizza joint.
Food Highlights
- Chili’s n Pep: Sweet heat alert! Cupping pepperoni and pickled jalapeños dance under a drizzle of honey, balanced by aged cheeses. Reviewers call it “greasy glory in every bite.”
- Mushroom Sally: Roasted oyster mushrooms meet garlic cream and white balsamic on this umami-packed pie—a vegetarian favorite.
- Prosciutto and Burrata: Creamy burrata melts over salty prosciutto, topped with arugula for a fresh, indulgent combo.
- The Hunter: Local bison chorizo and green chile ranch bring a Colorado twist to this spicy, meaty masterpiece.
Atmosphere
The vibe? Retro-cool meets mountain chill. Exposed brick, neon accents, and a rooftop patio with skyline views make it ideal for date nights or post-hike feasts.
Staff greet regulars by name, and the playlist leans into 70s rock—because nothing pairs with pizza like Fleetwood Mac.
Why It’s One of the Best in Colorado
Joy Hill nails the trifecta: craft-quality ingredients, inventive flavors, and a space that feels like a Denver block party.
Their sourdough crust—fermented for days—earns raves for its tangy chew, while happy hour deals (like $10 Margheritas) keep wallets happy.
Address: 1229 S Broadway, Denver, CO 80210
Antonio’s Real New York Pizza
Where Long Island meets the Rockies! Antonio’s Real New York Pizza in Estes Park serves up East Coast authenticity with a side of mountain charm.
Founded by a Long Island native, this family-owned spot has been slinging hand-tossed pies since 2014, using recipes passed down through generations.
Think crispy-thin crusts, tangy homemade marinara, and cheese that pulls like it’s auditioning for a commercial. Bonus: robots deliver your pizza, because why shouldn’t dinner feel like a sci-fi movie?
Food Highlights
- Sicilian Pizza: Thick, pan-cooked crust with cupping pepperoni that curls into crispy cups of flavor. A tribute to Long Island pizzerias.
- Grandma Pie: Thin-crust square pizza with fresh basil and garlic—so good it was the owner’s grandmother’s last meal.
- Neapolitan Pizza: Wood-fired perfection with homemade mozzarella and imported San Marzano tomatoes. Try the Sopressata & Red Pepper version for a spicy kick.
- Chicken Wing Pizza (off-menu secret): Sweet and spicy mango habanero sauce meets crispy wings—unexpectedly addictive.
- White Pizza: Creamy ricotta, garlic, and mushrooms atop a garlic-oil base. Topped with prosciutto? Chef’s kiss.
- Garlic Knots: Doughy, buttery, and showered in Parmesan—the ultimate sidekick.
Atmosphere
The vibe is casual and quirky, with red-and-white checkered tables, Star Wars-worthy robot servers, and walls plastered with NYC memorabilia.
Two fireplaces warm the 150-seat dining room, while patios offer views of the Rocky Mountains.
It’s family-friendly chaos with a soundtrack of clinking beer mugs and dough being hand-tossed behind the counter.
Why It’s One of the Best in Colorado
Antonio’s nails the holy trinity of great pizza: crust, sauce, and cheese. The dough ferments for days, the sauce simmers with Italian tomatoes, and the mozzarella is made in-house.
Add awards like Washington Post’s “Best NY Pizza in Colorado” and community initiatives (like free bread during COVID), and you’ve got a spot that’s as big-hearted as it is delicious.
Address: 1560 Big Thompson Ave, Estes Park, CO 80517