This family-owned gem brings authentic New York-style slices to Gilbert with decades of pizza-making tradition and the kind of hospitality that makes every customer feel like family.
Born from the legacy of the original Buono family that started crafting exceptional pies in 1989, this spot has evolved into a true local favorite where quality meets warmth. 🍕
How Buono’s won local’s hearts
Buono’s Pizza earned Gilbert’s devotion through a compelling combination of authentic Italian-American tradition and genuine family hospitality.
When Jimmy Pante, a New York native, originally took over the business from founder Vic Buono in 1994, he brought decades of East Coast pizza expertise to Arizona’s desert landscape.
After ownership changes through the years, Jimmy and his family returned to Gilbert in recent years, bringing their signature recipes and time-tested approach that made them legendary in the first place.
The secret to their success lies in their unwavering commitment to authenticity paired with their genuine care for every customer who walks through their doors.
Every pizza starts with fresh dough made daily in-house, using the same techniques Jimmy learned from the original Buono family recipe book.
The restaurant maintains that classic New York pizzeria atmosphere where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers are welcomed with genuine warmth.
Their dedication to using only the freshest local ingredients while staying true to traditional New York-style preparation methods has created a loyal following that spans generations of Gilbert families. ⭐
Food Highlights
- White Pizza: A creamy masterpiece featuring garlic butter, ricotta, and mozzarella on their signature thin crust that customers consistently rave about as one of their must-try specialties, with many reviewers calling it absolutely delicious and perfectly balanced
- Margherita Pizza The Buono Way: Fresh mozzarella magic with their homemade pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and stone deck oven baked, then finished with fresh tomato sauce and basil puree that delivers authentic Italian flavors in every single bite
- The Works Pizza (aka Supreme): Loaded with everything including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers, and onions on their signature Neapolitan-style thin crust, creating generous portions that often leave diners with delicious leftovers for the next day
- Meat Lovers Pizza: Carnivore paradise packed with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and bacon atop their fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella, delivering the hearty, protein-loaded experience that satisfies the biggest appetites with authentic New York-style preparation
- Tri White Pizza: Triple sauce sensation featuring their unique combination of housemade vodka sauce, pesto sauce, and tomato sauce with mozzarella, offering a creative twist that showcases the kitchen’s versatility and innovation while maintaining traditional quality standards
Atmosphere
Buono’s delivers that authentic New York neighborhood pizzeria vibe with a welcoming family atmosphere that makes every visit feel like coming home.
The interior features classic pizzeria decor with plenty of TVs for catching the game, comfortable seating arrangements, and that bustling energy you’d find in any great East Coast pizza joint. 🎵
The space strikes the perfect balance between casual dining and takeout convenience, with both indoor seating and outdoor options available for those who want to enjoy their meal al fresco.
Staff members are known for their friendly, attentive service and the kind of genuine hospitality that turns first-time visitors into regular customers, creating that neighborhood spot feeling where everyone truly feels welcome.
Also in Gilbert: 3 Amazing Pizza Restaurants to Try in Arizona
Bottom Line
- Authentic New York-style pizza made with fresh, daily-made dough and traditional techniques passed down through generations of pizza craftsmanship
- Family-owned hospitality where customers are treated like family and service goes above and beyond expectations every single visit 💫
- Generous portions and great value with large slices and hearty portions that often provide leftovers for the next day
- Loyalty program perks including pizza fridge magnets with large orders that lead to free pizzas after collecting ten magnets
- Fresh, quality ingredients sourced locally and prepared in-house daily, from dough to sauces to toppings
Address: 1464 E Williams Field Rd, Ste 108, Gilbert, AZ 85295
📞 (480) 899-1200
🕔 Mon-Tue: 11 AM–8 PM, Wed: 11 AM–9 PM, Thu-Fri: 11 AM–8 PM, Sat: 11 AM–9 PM, Sun: 12 PM–8 PM