Go To Destinations brings travelers the scoop on this local legend that keeps Odessa craving more.
Teak & Charlie’s Jersey Girl Pizza delivers authentic East Coast-style pies that transport taste buds straight to the Jersey boardwalk.
Brothers Teak and Charlie learned their craft from a Jersey girl named Emily, and now they’re serving up crispy thin-crust magic that has locals lining up for more. 🍕
How they won Odessa’s hearts
Word travels fast when pizza this good hits a small Texas town. What started as two brothers with a dream quickly became the talk of Odessa, with packed parking lots becoming the norm rather than the exception.
Customers rave about the no-flop thin crust that stays crispy even when loaded with toppings, while others compare it favorably to legendary New York establishments like Joe’s and John’s of Bleecker Street.
The secret sauce isn’t just in their recipe—it’s in their approach. These guys hand-toss every single pie using fresh ingredients and house-made dough that gets locals talking.
Reviews consistently praise the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio and that satisfying crunch that keeps people coming back week after week. One regular even joked about quitting their job just to eat here more often!
Food Highlights
- Margarita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil create this crowd-pleasing classic that showcases the restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients and perfect flavor balance
- Garden State Parkway: Loaded with mushrooms, green peppers, spinach, and red onions, this veggie-packed masterpiece proves that healthy can be absolutely delicious on thin crust
- Big Awesome Pizza: This massive 30-inch pie starts with mounds of hand-tossed dough and can accommodate any combination of their 30-plus toppings for sharing groups
- White Pizza: A cheese lover’s dream featuring premium mozzarella and seasonings that let the quality dairy shine without traditional tomato sauce competing for attention
- Hawaiian Pizza: Canadian bacon, pineapple, and banana peppers combine for a sweet and savory explosion that converts even the most skeptical pineapple-on-pizza critics 🏝️
Atmosphere
Step inside and you’ll discover a cozy throwback vibe that feels like an authentic 80s pizza joint.
The space stays buzzing with conversation and laughter, though seating fills up quickly during peak hours.
This BYOB establishment encourages guests to bring their favorite beverages while enjoying the relaxed, family-friendly environment.
Don’t expect fancy decor—the focus here stays firmly on incredible food and genuine hospitality that makes everyone feel welcome. ✨
ALSO IN ODESSA: 3 Outstanding Burger Spots to Try in Odessa, Texas
Bottom Line
Anyone seeking authentic East Coast pizza in West Texas needs to experience this local treasure.
The combination of perfectly executed thin-crust technique, fresh ingredients, and genuine passion for pizza craft creates something truly special.
Address: 4007 John Ben Shepperd Pkwy, Odessa, TX 79762
📞 (432) 366-2000
🕔 Open Mon-Sat, 11 AM–9 PM (closed Sun) 🕙