Are you looking for a pizza spot in Brooklyn that will send your taste buds on a journey through time and space? Ok, that is a bit dramatic, but we all crave a slice of pie that delivers the goods. And we are here to tell you that every spot on this list does just that.
Read on friends, and discover the best pizza spots Brooklyn has to offer! Bon appetit!
Juliana’s
No list of best Brooklyn pizzas would be complete without mentioning Juliana’s. Juliana’s is one of the more popular pizza places in Brooklyn.
It’s got a fascinating history as the “rival” of a next-door pizzeria, Grimaldi’s. In fact, the two pizzerias were founded by the same person — Patsy Grimaldi.
Long story short, Patsy first founded Grimaldi’s but retired in 1998. In 2012, he came out of retirement to open Juliana’s next door to Grimaldi’s.
Aside from its history, it’s undeniable that the pizza sets this establishment apart. They have set the bar high for other pizza places, and there are no reservations so expect long lines and waits.
There’s not a lot of customization you can do on the pizzas themselves, but when they’re already delicious, why change it? Their must-try is the Margherita pizza.
Menu: Juliana’s Menu
Top Review: “If anyone asks me what my favorite pizza place in NYC is, I’ll tell them Juliana’s without hesitation. While NYC has no shortage of great pizza spots, when I’m in the mood for pizza and have the time to enjoy it, I’m coming here – especially if I have a friend visiting. That’s how I came to visit the first time and have been back several times since. I’m not the only one who likes Juliana’s so there is typically a line out front as it’s not a large location but if you plan well, you won’t wait too long.” – Sarah M.
19 Old Fulton St Brooklyn, NY 11201, (718) 596-6700
Di Fara
Di Fara is in the Brooklyn books as a legendary pie shop, and if you’re a huge pizza fan, this should be on your Brooklyn checklist.
They make their dough fresh every morning and top it with quality and authentic Italian ingredients.
They offer regular pies, square pies, white pies, and specialty pies like the Chaos Pie. As in most popular pizza shops, there is a wait time. You can get your pizza by the slice or a whole box.
Top Review: “THE BEST PIZZA IVE HAD IN MY LIFE. Phil Rosenthal, thank you. If it wasn’t for Somebody Feed Phil, I wouldn’t even know about this place! The place is a staple in Brooklyn and their pizza is unmatched. The dough is perfectly airy, crispy, and light. The tomato sauce is homemade, perfectly seasoned and sweet topped with mozzarella and basil. It’s pure perfection and they’ve been slanging these pies longer than I’ve been alive.” – Hannah H.
1424 Ave J Brooklyn, NY 11230, (718) 258-1367
Lucali
If Lucali sounds familiar, you might have seen it featured on Netflix’s Ugly Delicious. They have a small and simple menu that relies on their excellent ingredients.
The spot is a little more upscale than typical pizzerias and has a bit of a rustic motif going on. Its cozy atmosphere makes it a great date night spot too.
If you’d like to have a little fun, you can build your own pizzas. They use both wood and gas-fired oven for your pies.
Top Review: “This was hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. Truly unbelievable, will be our new spot from now on. The BYOB thing was also great – we were able to put our names down, hang out for a bit and grab a bottle of wine, then head back and immediately be seated. The calzone was also incredible (we got garlic on ours). Absolutely amazing!! – Jake B.
575 Henry St Brooklyn, NY 11231, (718) 858-4086
Roberta’s
Roberta’s is a little out of the way from the usual tourist spots in Bushwick, but people think it’s worth it.
This pizzeria is so good that they already have multiple locations around the country. Their vibe is much more casual and hip and their pizzas are perfect for IG with those leopard-spotted crusts.
Pizzas come in traditional classic flavors, but their specialties are truly unique and interesting. Their most famous specialty is the Bee Sting Pizza.
Top Review: “This might just be the only spot that serves honey on pizza. I can understand why this is one of their most popular pizza. The bee sting pizza come with tomato, mozzarella, soppressata, basil, chili, and honey. It is cheesy, sweet and spicy at the same time. Must try!” – Katherine M.
261 Moore St Brooklyn, NY 11206, (718) 417-1118
Best Pizza
Best Pizza represents most of what tourists expect as the classic Brooklyn pizza. In true NY fashion, you can get your pizza by the slice and served to you on a white paper plate.
It’s a simple, no-frills type of place with walls lined with paper plate art from previous customers. Many people get the cheese pizza and customize it with different topping options.
Their pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven. If you’re looking for classic, delicious, and affordable, Best Pizza won’t disappoint.
Menu: Best Pizza Menu
Top Review: “This was hands down one of our favorite pizza places when visiting New York. Think: thin crispy crust that holds its weight without toppling over in your hand, a perfectly balanced tomato sauce and just the right amount of toppings and cheese. They also serve Mexican cokes so that scores them some serious brownie points. We visited on a Saturday night around 6pm and they were busy but the line moved quick. I personally loved the no-frills ambiance. The name lived up to the hype and it was well worth the trek from midtown Manhattan!” – Sim J.
33 Havemeyer St Brooklyn, NY 11211, (718) 599-2210
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s is arguably the most popular pizza place in the city and is what often comes to people’s minds when you ask them what the best pizza in Brooklyn is.
Their long history and fascinating rivalry with Juliana’s also give them that added layer of interest among pizza lovers.
Grimaldi specializes in coal-oven Neapolitan-style pies with various specialty pizzas, and you can also build your own.
Inside, art and murals adorned the walls, cozy lighting and that classic checkered pattern of a pizzeria.
You can expect long lines spilling out of the spot with lots of tourists eager to try why this is one of the best pizza places in Brooklyn.
People recommend their Margherita, garden pesto, prosciutto arugula, and Brooklyn bridge pizzas.
Menu: Grimaldi’s Pizza Menu
Top Review: “Love this place, every single time! Servers are always friendly. Drinks are always strong. Pizza is incredible. Gluten free crust is the best I’ve ever had. Can’t speak highly enough of this place. Always stop by when I’m in town.” – Sarah M.
1 Front St Brooklyn, NY 11201, (347) 687-6910
L & B Spumoni Gardens
L&B Spumoni Gardens is a family-owned and operated pizzeria that’s been with them for over four generations.
They are known for their Sicilian square pizza and their dessert, Spumoni. People have dubbed them as having “Brooklyn’s sexiest slices.”
They have pizza by the slice and, interestingly, use a deck oven (often used for bread) for cooking their pizza. The ambiance is casual and simple, with lots of seating and outdoor picnic tables.
Menu: L & B Spumoni Menu
Top Review: “I am a very big fan of Sicilian pizzas and have come here a few times to satisfy my pizza cravings. The sicilian pies are very large, very saucy, good amount of cheese and the crust is not too crispy and not too soft. No toppings are needed because it is already very flavorful and delicious.” – Vincent L.
2725 86th St Brooklyn, NY 11223, (718) 449-1230
Speedy Romeo
Speedy Romeo offers wood-oven pizza, wood-fired steak, wines, and craft beers. They are also a little more upscale than others, with a vintage vibe in their restaurant and art surrounding you.
Speedy Romeo is known more for their specialty pizzas like Saint Louie, King Salami, and Dangerfield.
You should also try their kind brother pizza and white album pizza.
Menu: Speedy Romeo
Top Review: “The pepperoni classic w a truffle ranch drizzle–the stuff of dreams. Staff are incredibly friendly and you can sit indoors or outdoors depending on the weather.” – Rita L.
376 Classon Ave Brooklyn, NY 11238, (718) 230-0061
You might also like drooling over these pizza articles:
- The Best Pizza Spots in Lancaster, Ohio
- Best Pizza in Denver, Colorado
- Best Pizza Spots in Tucson, Arizona
- Best Pizza in San Diego, California
pizza in brooklyn, best pizza in brooklyn, brooklyn pizza, pizza spots in brooklyn,best pizza brooklyn, famous pizzerias in brooklyn, best pizza brooklyn ny, best pizza restaurants in brooklyn, brooklyns best pizza, best pizza in brooklyn ny, brooklyn pizza places, famous brooklyn pizzerias, brooklyn pizza best, famous pizza in brooklyn
