This tiny yellow diner in Anderson, Indiana has been serving up authentic 1950s charm and handcrafted burgers since 1954.
The Lemon Drop proves that sometimes the best things come in small packages, with only 27 seats but a reputation that draws crowds daily.
Locals and travelers alike make pilgrimages here for the famous onion burger and old-school atmosphere complete with a model train circling overhead. đźš‚
How they won local’s hearts
The Lemon Drop captured Anderson’s heart by staying true to its roots for over 70 years.
When most restaurants chase trends, this family-owned gem maintained its original 1950s decor, including vintage Coca-Cola machines, jukeboxes, and record albums hanging on walls.
Owner Bill Pitts has dedicated 56 years to the business, creating consistency that builds trust with generations of customers.
The restaurant’s legendary onion burger became the cornerstone of its success. This signature creation features two thin beef patties with grilled onions cooked directly between them, creating a unique flavor profile that customers can’t find elsewhere.
Word-of-mouth marketing proved more powerful than any advertising campaign, as satisfied diners became ambassadors, bringing friends and family to experience this Indiana institution.
The incredibly affordable prices – with complete meals under $10 – made it accessible to everyone, from teenagers on dates to families seeking budget-friendly dining. 💰
Food Highlights
- Onion Burger: Two thin beef patties with grilled onions cooked between them – their claim to fame and the “#1 burger in Indiana” 🍔
- Double Onion Cheeseburger: Extra beef patties make this hearty option perfect for bigger appetites
- Cheeseburger on Toast: Classic burger served on buttery grilled bread with lettuce, tomato, and mayo
- Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich: Crispy, tender pork with perfect seasoning – a true Hoosier favorite
- Lemon Shake: Thick, creamy vanilla shake with a perfect citrusy twist – sweet and tart balance ✨
- Shoestring Fries: Crispy, hot fries that complement every burger perfectly
Atmosphere
The authentic 1950s ambiance transports visitors back in time. A model train continuously circles the ceiling while customers enjoy meals at the L-shaped counter or four cozy booths.
The bright yellow exterior and vintage neon sign create an unmistakable landmark.
Lightning-fast service and genuinely friendly staff maintain the small-town Indiana hospitality that keeps people returning. 🌟
Bottom Line
The Lemon Drop delivers an authentic slice of Americana with exceptional food at unbeatable prices.
This isn’t manufactured nostalgia – it’s the real deal, making it essential for anyone seeking genuine local flavor and legendary burgers.
Address: 1701 Mounds Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
đź“ž (765) 644-9055
🕔 Mon-Sat 10:30 AM–9:00 PM (Closed Sun)