Why This is One of THE BEST Barbecue Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN

By Jeremy Schwegmann
Best BBQBlogDestinationsIndiana

Hold onto your napkins, Indy! 🤠🔥

Smokin’ Barrel BBQ slings mouthwatering smoke magic that’ll make your taste buds line-dance.

Tucked inside a bingo hall (yes, you read that right!), this family-owned gem dishes out low-and-slow perfection with a side of small-town charm.

Think tender meats, scratch-made sides, and banana pudding so good it’ll make you clap. 🍖🎰💃

Food Highlights

  • Brisket Sandwich: Juicy, melt-in-your-mouth slices with a perfect smoke ring—no sauce needed. Crowd favorite for its buttery texture and smoky bark.
  • Rib Tips Dinner: Fall-off-the-bone tender with a sweet-and-savory dry rub. Regulars call it “Indiana’s best-kept secret.”
  • Pulled Pork Dinner: Sugar-free rub lets the pork’s natural flavors shine—ideal for keto fans. Paired with corn casserole (a creamy, crunchy obsession).
  • Meat Fight Sandwich: A carnivore’s dream piled high with brisket, pork, and sausage. Bring your appetite.
  • Banana Pudding: Creamy, nostalgic, and homemade—dessert lovers swear it’s worth the drive alone.
  • Mac & Cheese: Ultra-creamy with a golden crust. Even “mac-haters” convert after one bite.
Juicy barbecue ribs with shredded pork, baked beans, potato salad, coleslaw, mac and cheese, and barbecue sauce on a wooden platter. Perfect for a Southern barbecue feast.
Will

Atmosphere

Step into a no-frills, big-flavor vibe inside a community bingo hall. Picnic tables, friendly chatter, and servers who treat you like family.

Parking-lot picnics are encouraged—grab your tray and dig in under the Indiana sky.

Why It’s One of the Best in Indiana

Smokin’ Barrel BBQ masters the art of patience: 14+ hours of smoking over local wood.

Family-run since 2016, they’re community heroes (4H supporters, church volunteers) who prioritize flavor over fuss.

Keto-friendly? Check. Generous portions? Double-check. Come for the meat, stay for the green beans that’ll make veggie skeptics swoon.

Address: 2316 S German Church Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46239