Don’t Sleep on These 2 Amazing Hidden Gem Restaurants in Aurora, CO!

Hey Aurora! Have you tried these two hidden gems?

Dive into Aurora’s dining scene with Athenian Restaurant and Pomodoro Pizza Pasta, each offering a unique slice of world cuisine right in your backyard. From the heartwarming Greek hospitality at Athenian to the cozy Italian charm of Pomodoro, these spots promise not just meals but memorable experiences. Let’s explore what makes these restaurants the talk of the town!

Athenian Restaurant

Athenian Restaurant in Aurora, CO, offers an unparalleled dining experience, delivering the best Greek cuisine many have ever had. Travelers and locals alike rave about the exceptional customer service and the even more remarkable food.

The staff, including the owners, extend a warm, family-like welcome to every guest, making each visit memorable. A visit to Athenian Restaurant promises not just a meal but an encounter with authentic Greek hospitality and flavors that linger long after the last bite.

Food Highlights

  • Hummus: Highly recommended for its perfect blend of flavors.
  • Kefta: Praised for its complex flavors and beautiful presentation.
  • Saganaki: Stands out for its exquisite taste; a must-try.
  • Pasta with Meatballs: Surprisingly delightful, surpassing expectations.
  • Gyro/Pork/Chicken Platter: Offers a taste of various Greek meats.
  • Mousakka, Pattitsio, Dolmades, Spanakopita Platter: A platter that allows diners to sample multiple Greek classics.


Athenian Restaurant boasts a cozy, homely atmosphere, akin to being invited into a Greek family’s home. The Greek ambiance is authentic, enhanced by the option to enjoy Greek beer and wine, making every dining experience feel like a special occasion.

Bottom line: Athenian Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Greek cuisine and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The blend of delicious food, exceptional service, and a cozy environment makes it a standout destination for a memorable dining experience.

Location: 15350 E Iliff Ave Aurora, CO 80013

Pomodoro Pizza Pasta Pizza Pasta in Aurora, CO, surprises many with its exceptional Italian cuisine, despite its modest setting in a strip mall. This unassuming spot impresses with its clean interior and warm hospitality, offering a slice of New York’s cozy charm right in Aurora.

The owners, known for their kindness, ensure every guest feels at home, contributing to the restaurant’s inviting atmosphere. Their menu, bursting with flavors, promises a memorable dining experience for anyone who visits.

Food Highlights

  • Fried Ravioli & Garlic Knots: A perfect start with well-balanced marinara sauce.
  • Lasagna: Layered with deliciousness in every bite.
  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken and Mushrooms: A creamy, magical blend that’s hard to forget.
  • Meat Lovers Pizza: Possibly the best you’ll ever have, loaded with toppings.
  • Chicken Marsala & Eggplant Parmesan: Rich flavors that elevate simple pasta.
  • Shrimp Scampi: Not just butter and garlic, but a beautifully balanced dish with jumbo shrimp.


The restaurant’s interior is simple yet very clean, creating a nice sit-down ambiance beyond the typical take-out expectation. It’s a small and cute space, meticulously maintained, where the staff’s friendliness adds to the cozy, welcoming vibe. With a few tables available, it offers an intimate dining experience that makes you feel like part of the family.

Bottom Line: Pomodoro Pizza Pasta stands as a must-visit for its outstanding Italian dishes, exceptional service, and cozy atmosphere. It’s a place where the quality of food and the sincerity of hospitality make every meal special.

Location: 576 Dayton St Aurora, CO 80010