Columbus is more than just Buckeye pride and the birthplace of Wendy’s. It’s a city brimming with secret spots where flavors burst like confetti. Ready to ditch the mainstream and explore the delicious underbelly of this foodie haven?
Here are the best hidden gem restaurants that will make you the hero of your next dinner outing.
Understory
Understory in Columbus offers a delightful escape from the ordinary dining experience. Housed in a transformed historic building, this hidden gem combines a relaxed atmosphere with a menu that surprises and delights.
Guests order at the counter, allowing them to savor the anticipation as they await their carefully crafted dishes. The friendly staff enhances the welcoming vibe, making every visit feel special.
Food Highlights
- Toad in the Hole: A comforting classic featuring eggs nestled in toasted bread, reminiscent of childhood favorites.
- Mini Donuts: A sharable treat with four tempting flavors—salted caramel, apple compote, whipped cream, and cinnamon sugar.
- Shrimp and Grits: A standout dish that showcases inventive flavors and seasonal ingredients.
Atmosphere
The patio at Understory provides a unique dining experience, surrounded by nature and equipped with charming fire pits. Guests can enjoy their meals under tree canopies, creating a cozy setting that feels both intimate and inviting. Inside, the warm decor complements the friendly service, ensuring a memorable visit.
Bottom Line
Understory is a must-visit for anyone in Columbus seeking great food and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether stopping by for brunch before a concert or enjoying a quiet dinner, this restaurant promises a delightful experience.
Location: 2571 Neil Ave Columbus, OH 43202
Alqueria Farmhouse Kitchen
Alqueria Farmhouse Kitchen in Columbus is a hidden gem that delights diners with its commitment to fresh, farm-to-table fare. This charming eatery offers an inviting atmosphere paired with a menu that changes frequently, ensuring each visit feels special. Patrons rave about the quality of the food and the attentive service, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers.
Food Highlights
- Shrimp and Drunken Goat Cheese: A standout appetizer, the shrimp is perfectly cooked and served in a flavorful oil that keeps diners coming back for more.
- Lamb: Tender and juicy, the lamb effortlessly falls off the bone, offering a melt-in-your-mouth experience.
- Farm House Burger: Topped with pimento cheese, this burger surprises with its rich flavor, though be sure to specify your preferred doneness.
- Duck Confit Gnocchi: A must-try when available, this dish showcases the kitchen’s expertise in crafting delightful comfort food.
Atmosphere
The upscale-rustic setting of Alqueria creates a warm and cozy vibe, perfect for intimate dinners or gatherings with friends. The limited seating adds to its charm, making reservations essential for a guaranteed spot.
Bottom Line
Visiting Alqueria Farmhouse Kitchen guarantees a memorable dining experience filled with fresh flavors and exceptional service. The seasonal menu and commitment to quality make it a top choice for anyone seeking a delightful meal in Columbus.
Location: 247 King Ave Columbus, OH 43201
Bonifacio
Located in Columbus, Bonifacio is a hidden gem that delights diners with its flavorful dishes and inviting atmosphere. Originally discovered by most through a viral TikTok, this restaurant has become a must-visit spot. Patrons are drawn to Bonifacio not just for the food but for the warm, friendly service and vibrant environment.
Food Highlights
- BBQ Chicken Skewers: A must-try dish, perfect for sharing.
- Lumpia: Crispy and delicious, ideal for catering events.
- Chicken Thighs Rice Combo: Balanced with protein, carbs, and vegetables.
- Pork Belly Rice Combo: Another flavorful and hearty option.
- Sautéed Bok Choi: Sweet and savory, a perfect appetizer.
- Adobo Ribs: Tender and well-prepared, though some may find it lacking in flavor.
- Chicken Sizzling Sisig: A popular main course that some find just okay.
Atmosphere
Bonifacio boasts a family-run, cozy atmosphere that feels both fun and relaxed. The decor around the bar adds a charming touch, and despite the small space, the seating arrangement is comfortable.
Expect a bustling environment, especially on weekend evenings, so reservations are recommended. The service is polite, efficient, and attentive, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Bottom Line
Bonifacio in Columbus offers a delightful mix of flavorful dishes and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. From the highly recommended BBQ Chicken Skewers to the balanced rice combos, there’s something for everyone. Perfect for both casual dining and special events, Bonifacio is a spot worth visiting.
Location: 1577 King Ave Columbus, OH 43212