Oklahoma City’s pizza scene found its authentic New York slice when Pronto New York Style Pizza opened its doors.
This family-owned pizzeria brings the genuine taste of the Big Apple straight to NW 36th Street, serving up hand-tossed thin crust pies that transport locals from the plains to the bustling streets of Manhattan with every bite. 🍕
How Pronto’s won local’s hearts
Pronto’s rise to neighborhood favorite happened through their commitment to authentic New York-style preparation and fresh, quality ingredients.
The pizzeria’s thin, foldable crust and rich tomato sauce quickly became a hit among locals craving that genuine East Coast experience.
Customer reviews consistently praise the generous toppings, perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, and the crispy yet foldable texture that defines true New York pizza.
The restaurant’s success stems from their no-nonsense approach to pizza making – 100 percent whole-milk mozzarella, fresh dough made from scratch, and house-made sauce that customers describe as flavorful and authentic.
Regular patrons rave about the consistency, with many noting how each visit delivers the same high-quality experience they’ve come to expect.
The pizzeria’s generous portion sizes and reasonable pricing have made it a go-to spot for families and pizza lovers throughout the area. 🏆
Food Highlights
- Margherita Pizza: Classic red sauce topped with fresh mozzarella, aromatic basil, and a drizzle of olive oil that creates the perfect balance of flavors on their signature thin crust
- Garden of Eatin: A vegetable lover’s dream featuring green peppers, mushrooms, onions, spinach, and tomatoes that customers consistently describe as fresh and delicious with generous portions
- Pronto Special Pizza: Their signature pie loaded with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, hamburger, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, and black olives – a hearty combination that showcases their generous topping philosophy
- Classic Meat Lovers: A protein-packed powerhouse featuring pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, and hamburger that meat enthusiasts consistently praise for its bold flavors and satisfying portions
- White Pizza: A unique ricotta cheese base topped with onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach, finished with mozzarella cheese that offers a creamy, flavorful alternative to traditional red sauce pies 🍴
Atmosphere
Pronto’s casual, neighborhood vibe creates a welcoming environment for quick slices or family dinners.
The restaurant operates primarily as a carry-out spot but offers a few tables for dining in when you want to savor your slice on-site.
The friendly staff and straightforward setup reflect the authentic New York pizza shop experience – no frills, just great pizza served with genuine hospitality.
The space maintains that classic pizzeria feel where the focus remains squarely on delivering quality food rather than fancy décor. 🏪
Bottom Line
- Authentic New York-style pizza with thin, foldable crust that locals consistently praise
- Fresh, quality ingredients including 100% whole-milk mozzarella and house-made sauce
- Generous portions at reasonable prices that provide excellent value
- Friendly service in a relaxed, neighborhood atmosphere perfect for quick meals or family dining
- Consistent quality that keeps customers coming back for more authentic East Coast flavor 💯
Address: 2311 NW 36th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73112
📞 (405) 998-2228
🕔 Tue-Sun 4 PM–10 PM (closed Mon)