The Supremes: The BEST Pizza Places in Greenville, SC

Do you know that pizza is one of the few tasty dishes that go well with pineapple? Not all foods can match up with the sweetness or sourness of this fruit. But with pizza, it is considered a well-established topping, particularly with Hawaiian Pizza. 

Pizza alone is one savory dish that everyone loves. It does not matter what the toppings are. It can be any meat, vegetables, or eat it plain. 

Here in Greenville, South Carolina, the list below is some of the best pizza places to visit for your friends or family to gather and enjoy.

D’Allesandro’s Pizza

Established in 2018, D’Allesandro’s Pizza is a family-friendly neighborhood pizza restaurant.

They served hand-tossed pizzas that are prepared in New York style. It can be folded easily for that perfect bite. Pair it up with their wide selection of beer and wine.

D’Allesandro’s Pizza has every pizza categorized into each individual’s preference. For their signature meat pizzas, try their Meat Lovers, which is made of red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.

For their Hand Tossed DAL’s Pizza, try their Supreme Pizza, with red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, red onions, and button mushrooms.

They also have signature vegetarian pizzas. Try the Greek pizza, with red sauce, mozzarella, spinach, tomato, black olives, banana peppers, and feta cheese. 

Menu: D’Allesandro’s Menu

Top Review: “First spot I stopped at on my visit to Greenville. The atmosphere & vibe are so cool and relaxing. The pizza was amazing! I ordered the hyped experience but added spinach & green peppers. Had such a great spicy but sweet flavor. One of the best pizzas I’ve had! The fruit punch mimosa was very tasty & different, had kiwi flavor & was way better than the regular OJ.”Hannah S.

D’Allesandro’s Pizza is located at 17 Mohawk Dr. Greenville, SC 29609, (864) 989-0100

Della Ventura’s Ristorante and Pizzeria

Photo: Brett H.

Serving mouthwatering pizza dishes for 50 years, Della Ventura’s Ristorante and Pizzeria opened in 1972. It is a family-owned business that first started in Staten Island, New York.

Now they have over 5 pizzeria businesses in the US. One of their locations is at 337 S. Buncombe Road, Greer, SC.

The Della Ventura’s Ristorante and Pizzeria have 25 toppings to choose from. For guests that prefer their pizza that is filled with toppings, go with Stuffed Pizza. It is made of pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, and mozzarella. They also have a Gluten-Free Pizza for guests that are allergic to gluten.

Menu: Della Ventura’s Menu

Top Review: “Fantastic, authentic, family owned Italian restaurant.  The closest I have ever found to neighborhood Italian restaurants in the northeast.  Dishes and sauces were unique, the kind you will never find in Olive Garden.  Prices affordable, portions large.  Its a casual family restaurant with limited seating for large parties. If in a rush consider takeout, either by calling ahead or ordering person. Staff is friendly, efficient with lots of helpful suggestions.  This is my new go to place for Italian.” – Richard L.

337 S Buncombe Rd Greer, SC 29650, (864) 989-0100

Antonio Bertolo’s Pizza

Photo: Antonio Bertolo’s

For pizza lovers that are looking for a pizzeria that has years of experience in cooking in the finest restaurants, Antonio Bertolo’s Pizza is the right fit for you.

Their chef has over 20 years of experience. With this background, they have learned the value of quality.

Hence, they refuse to compromise it. All their ingredients are fresh and are sourced from the local farmer’s markets.

Antonio Bertolo’s Pizza offers several specialty pizzas that guests can order. They have Supreme Pizza, which is made of pepperoni, sausage, beef, Canadian bacon, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese.

For guests that like to eat vegetables in their pizza, they have Veggie Pizza, which is made of mushrooms, onion, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese.

Menu: Antonio Bertolo’s Menu

Top Review:My boyfriend and I’s favorite pizza place in Greenville! The pizza is great and the wings are amazing! It’s our go to take out pizza place. The staff is super nice as well!”Anecia H.

200 N Main St, Greenville, SC 29601, (864) 467-9555

Barley’s

A regular recipient of local awards for its tasty pizza, Barley’s restaurant had been continuously giving its patrons the best meals for 15 years.

They are not only known for their pizza, but their wide variety of beer to go with it. They also offer calzones, a favorite among the locals, sandwiches, pasta, and salads.

Barley’s serves New York-style pizza. You can try their White Pizza, which is made of ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan cheese, garlic, and herbs.

You also have the option to choose your own topics, from different meats, cheese, and veggies. Try out their specialty pizza as well.

You can never go wrong with their Meat Eater, which is made of a classic marinara base, bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, and ground beef.

Menu: Barley’s Menu

Top Review: “It doesn’t get any better than pizza and beer and this place tops them both! I came here for lunch one day and grabbed a slice of pizza with a side salad and of course, a bev. They were short staffed, but who isn’t right now? The pizza was crispy, salad flavorful and their selection of beers on tap is plentiful! There is an upstairs that I need to go visit that they open at night that has different options than the downstairs. I will go back to try the upstairs experience for sure!”Tracy C.

25 W Washington St., Greenville, SC 29601, (864) 232-3706

Sidewall Pizza

Sidewall Pizza is popular for its community fund project. Not only do they deliver quality pizza dishes, but for every dime they earn, they dedicate a portion of their proceeds to the community fund.

They use this to donate to families, organizations, or individuals that are in need. So, if you want to give back to the community, this restaurant is perfect for your cause.

Sidewall Pizza is popular among locals and tourists. All their ingredients are fresh so rest assured that the pizza you are eating is delicious.

They have various pizza options, crushed tomato sauce pizzas, roasted garlic sauce pizzas, basil pesto pizzas, rosemary garlic oil pizzas, chicken pizzas, stuffed pizzas, and build your own pizzas. 

Menu: Sidewall Menu

Top Review: “Yes yes yes!!! I’m obsessed with their stuffed pizza and I can’t wait to go back! It’s loaded with meat and cheese.  Their sauce is slightly sweet offering a flavor I’ve never tasted before but I was craving for more with every bite.  We also had the buffalo chicken dip…. Let’s just say… my dad literally licked the little pan it came in.” – Melissa L.

Sidewall Pizza is located at 99 Cleveland St. Greenville, SC 29601, (864) 558-0235

The Slice (Formerly Slice of Brooklyn Pizza)

Bring it on! Photo: Jamie S.

For tourists that wish to taste the best of New York-style pizza in Greenville, The Slice of Brooklyn Pizza is a popular place to eat this dish.

The owners have been in the restaurant business for 40 years. Although raised in Brooklyn, Cosimo and Carmela are both born in Italy.

It is their goal to bring the taste of Italy to the area by using the finest ingredients thus his recipe brings out the best in all his dishes. 

Some of the Slice of Brooklyn Pizza highlights are their Gourmet Chicken Pizza, Gourmet White Pizza, and Gourmet Red Pizza. They also serve appetizers, salads, parmigiana, and desserts. 

If you are looking for a relaxing night out with friends, join the Slice of Brooklyn Pizza on Thursday, Friday, or Saturday for a Live Music session.

Menu: The Slice Menu

Top Review: “OK, so I have given 5 stars to a few other pizza places during my time on Yelp but HEAR ME, THIS ONE IS DEFINITELY THE BEST I’ve had in SC and among the best including NY/NJ pizza places. We had a plain pie with double sauce and double cheese and it was very impressive. The sauce was among the most flavorful that I’ve had anywhere and the cheese was as good as anywhere I’ve ever been.”Scott S.

They are located at 134 S Main St Simpsonville, SC 29681, (864) 757-9330

Coastal Crust

Created to serve pizza in a unique way, Coastal Crust served their delicious pizza in a restored 1950’s classic truck.

To bring out the best of Neopolitan-style pizza, they have a custom-designed wood-fired Valoriani pizza oven. All their pizza is made from scratch using the finest ingredients that are hand-rolled daily to provide its guests with the freshest tasting crust.

In addition to their well-known wood-fired pizzas, they also provide Italian-inspired dishes. 

When visiting Coastal Crust, try their Fig & Prosciutto pizza, which is made of truffle oil, gorgonzola, and house hot honey.

Another popular pizza dish is the Toasted Pistachio & Speck, which is made of olive oil, smoked Italian ham, stracciatella, pesto, and crushed pistachios.

However, if you are allergic to peanuts, try their West Village Pizza instead. It is made of crushed tomato sauce, pepperoni, fennel sausage, stracciatella, caramelized onions, and roasted red peppers.

Top Review: “Fabulous! We went with two other couples and we were all very pleased with our pizza. I had a green salad (yum!) and the fig and prosciutto pizza and IT WAS TO DIE FOR!”Carrie M.

1254 Pendleton Street, Greenville, SC 29611, (864) 412-8501

Belladina’s Pizza

If you are looking for something good to eat, try Belladina’s Pizza. Considered one of the best pizzas in Greenville, this restaurant remains a popular place despite many competitors in the area. With its fresh ingredients and classic pizza, guests are treated to a delicious and savory meal.

Serving Neopolitan traditional crust, visit Belladinaa’s Pizza and check what’s the buzz about. Their popular pizza dish is the Classic Pizza, which is made of classic cheese. Another popular dish is the Detroit-style pizza, which is pan-baked.

Menu:

Top Review:

Belladina’s Pizza is located at 9 W Washington St. Greenville, SC 29601.

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza opened in 1998 in Charlotte, North Carolina. Since then they have opened 26 more locations including Greenville, South Carolina. What makes this pizzeria popular is its value for the quality of pizza they serve. They always provide consistent high-quality ingredients. 

What makes Brixx Wood Fired Pizza unique is its traditional crust, which is vegan. You have the option to choose Brixx Classics Pizza, such as Sausage & Spicy Honey Pizza, which is made of spicy sausage crumbled over a four-cheese blend, house recipe tomato sauce, baked then drizzled with sriracha-infused honey. You can also try their Veggie Lovers Pizza, such as Wood-Roasted Vegetable, which is made of wild mushrooms, broccoli, onions, peppers, and fresh oregano with their house recipe tomato sauce & mozzarella. 

Menu:

Top Review:

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza is located at 1125 Woodruff Rd. Suite 1601 Greenville, SC 29607.

Pizza City New York Style

For guests that prefer a low-key pizza restaurant but can still provide tasty dishes, Pizza City New York Style is the place to go. The casual attitude is what draws the attention of both locals and visitors to the place. Their New York-style pizza is guaranteed delicious with its hand-tossed dough and fresh toppings.

If you want a unique pizza style, try Pizza City Works, which is made up of pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon, onion, mushrooms, bell peppers, green and black olives, ham, banana peppers, and jalapenos. If you like meat, try their Pizza City Meat Eaters Special, which is made of pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, beef, and bacon. For guests who like their pizza to be simple, try their Greek Pizza, which is made of pizza sauce, petaled onions, black olives, mozzarella, and feta cheese. 

Menu:

Top Review:

Pizza City New York Style is located at 1547 N Pleasantburg Dr. Greenville, SC 29609.

Sciortino’s Trattoria & Pizzaria

New York is known for its pizza style. Imagine that freshness and quality right in Greenville. Sciortino’s Trattoria & Pizzaria is not only a traditional Italian Cuisine but one of the best New York-style pizzas in the neighborhood. All their pizza dish is prepared using the finest and freshest ingredients. Their recipes are handed down through generations making them maintain their quality and unique flavor.

If you are unsure about what to order, you can never go wrong with Margherita Pizza, which is made of their traditional marinara sauce, topped with their homemade fresh mozzarella. If you wish to level up your pizza, try their Chicken A La Vodka Pizza, which is made of chicken sauteed in a la vodka sauce with mozzarella cheese. 

Menu:

Top Review:

Sciortino’s Trattoria & Pizzaria is located at 3734 Pelham Rd., Greenville, SC 29615.

Merrell’s Pizza

Established in 2012, Merrell’s Pizza offers a wide range of delicious dishes, such as pizza and chicken wings. Carefully crafted to satisfy the taste buds of their guests, it is the owners’ dream to serve the best pizza in their community. Ray Merheb and Willis Terrell worked hard to achieve what they have today. Due to its success, they were able to open its second branch by 2016.

For guests that is an avid fan of cheese, try their Cheese Pizza. Taste the mouthwatering cheese as it melts in your mouth with every bite. You can also try some of Merrell’s specialty pizzas such as The Mile High Pizza Pie, Meat Pie, Alfredo Chicken Pie, and many more.

Menu:

Top Review:

Merrell’s Pizza is located at 1207 W. Poinsett St. Greer, SC 292650 and 101 N.E. Main St. Easley, SC 29640.

Myle’s Pizza Pub

Serving the community since 2016, Myle’s Pizza Pub introduces its pizza style that has made them a household favorite back in Ohio. Bringing their skills and expertise in creating pizza to Greenville, Myle’s was able to maintain its unique way of delivering pizza, making them a local favorite. This pizzeria boasts its fresh ingredients and makes the sauce from scratch. This secret sauce takes two days to prepare to ensure that it achieves its famous flavor. 

If you find yourself touring the area, try their Meat Lovers Pizza, which is made of ground beef, sausage, ham, and Canadian Bacon. Their Food Lovers is also a popular pizza dish made of sausage, beef, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, black olives, ham, green peppers, onions, and extra cheese. 

Menu:

Top Review:

Myle’s Pizza Pub is located at 555 S Pleasantburg Dr. Greenville, SC 29607.

Pangaea Brewing Co.

For tourists that love the idea of a relaxing atmosphere where people are brought together while enjoying pizza and beer, Pangea Brewing Co. is the perfect place for this. Tourists get to eat what they love. Their ingredients are sourced from local farmers. 

Their pizzas are uniquely crafted using their style and the menu is subject to seasonal adjustments. Their pizza menu is Cheese, American, South Carolina, Foragers, Vietnamese, Italian, and Spanish. If you wish to try local food choices, try their South Carolina Pizza, which is made of house-made beer mustard base, coal-braised pork butt, shredded red cabbage, locally aged cheddar, and bacon jam. Another popular dish is the Foragers, which is made of truffle oil base, locally sourced mushrooms, marinated cherry tomato, pecorino romano, local honey, herbed bread crumb, and arugula.

Menu:

Top Review:

Pangaea Brewing Co is located at 115 Welborn St., Greenville, SC 29601.

Todaro’s Pizza

Established in 2000, Todaro’s Pizza has been serving the community for over 20 years. All their pizza is made of fresh ingredients so customers are guaranteed good quality pizza. Every Monday they celebrate Cheap Pizza Night, so the community can gather and enjoy a relaxing night with friends and good food.

Todaro’s Pizza serves Traditional Pizzas, Stuffed Pizzas, and Specialty Pizzas. For the Traditional Pizza, try their Primavera, which is made of peppers, tomatoes, broccoli, and mushrooms. For the stuffed pizzas, try their House Style Stuffed Pizza, which is stuffed with mozzarella, Italian sausage, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, and peppers. For their Specialty Pizzas, try the Roasted Red & White, which has a base of smooth ricotta cheese topped with roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese. This pizza dish is great when added with additional grilled chicken toppings. 

Menu:

Top Review:

Todaro’s Pizza is located at 105 Sloan St., Clemson, SC 29631.

People from around the world are always brought together through food and drinks. The idea of enjoying great company and making memories is relaxing and good for destressing. That’s the reason why Pizza is always considered comfort food by many. It is the perfect treat for every occasion.