If you ask any long-time Columbus local where to find the city’s absolute best tavern-cut pizza, they won’t point you toward the trendy, sit-down spots in the Short North or downtown.
Instead, they’ll tell you to head straight up Cleveland Avenue to a modest, old-school carry-out counter that’s been quietly anchoring the North End since Dwight D. Eisenhower was in office.
It’s the kind of place where the paper bags are heavy, the staff treats you like family, and the recipes have remained blissfully untouched for generations.
Quick Bite – Terita’s Pizza, Columbus, OH 🤯
What truly stuns first-time visitors is how a tiny, no-frills neighborhood outpost can deliver a product so vastly superior to the mass-produced, portion-controlled menu options of modern delivery chains.
While national fast-food spots resort to frozen, pre-fabricated meat pellets, the hands-on kitchen team here prepares their legendary custom Italian sausage by hand from scratch using Gus Iannarino’s private 1959 family recipe.
That unrelenting dedication to premium raw ingredients yields a beautiful, thin Columbus-style crust that holds its crispness under a remarkably heavy layer of toppings.
Operating under the proud stewardship of Gus’s son Tom, this tiny operation continues to set the city’s gold standard for old-school baking, cementing its role as a definitive local mom and pops and hole in the wall classic.
The Local Atmosphere – Terita’s Pizza, Columbus, OH 😍
Picking up your order here is a wonderfully straightforward, no-nonsense affair. You walk up to a simple, compact counter, pay the cashier, and grab your piping-hot box directly from the staff.
There are no tables, no hostess stands, and absolutely no corporate pretense—just a decades-old pickup window that smells heavily of toasted fennel, melted cheese, and fresh dough.
It is a pure grab-and-go neighborhood hub where local families from Clintonville, Linden, and Minerva Park have happily traded quick pleasantries with the staff for over six decades while picking up their weekend dinner.
Signature Bites – Terita’s Pizza, Columbus, OH 😋
-
Terita’s Special Pizza: A spectacular thin-crust masterpiece loaded with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and generous clumps of their homemade Italian sausage.
-
Double Italian Sub: A towering toasted classic packing a massive, double-layer portion of provolone, ham, salami, and spicy capicola inside a crusty Italian sub bun.
-
Terita’s Meat Lovers Pizza: A carnivore’s dream pairing savory ham, crispy bacon, and pepperoni with thick, juicy sausage toppings spread across a perfectly blistered crust.
-
Homemade Sausage Sub: A comforting lunchtime staple highlighting the kitchen’s signature seasoned meat, topped with melted provolone and spicy hot peppers on a toasted roll.
-
Terita’s White Pizza: A wonderfully fragrant alternative swapping traditional red sauce for high-quality olive oil, minced garlic, oregano, provolone, and a dusting of romano cheese.
-
Oven-Roasted Wings: A savory crowd-pleaser featuring plump chicken wings baked in the stone ovens until the skin turns incredibly crisp and golden-brown.
Takeaway Bite – Terita’s Pizza, Columbus, OH 😎
Choosing a quiet drive down Cleveland Avenue over a trendy, overhyped downtown dinner spot pays off the exact moment you lift your first tavern-cut square from the box.
By uniting a flawless, 1950s-era family culinary work ethic with mind-blowing homemade ingredients and an incredibly welcoming community spirit, this neighborhood carry-out champion proves that the best meals in Columbus are still served over a simple counter inside a true mom and pops and hole in the wall icon.
📍: 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224
🕒: Sun-Thu: 4:00 PM – 9:30 PM; Fri-Sat: 4:00 PM – 10:30 PM