Looking for the best Italian in Miami? Making a selection of the top Italian restaurants in Miami is challenging as the city is overflowing with exceptional choices. To help you in your food adventure, we’ve curated a list of some of the best Italian restaurants in Miami.
You’ll find welcoming Italian eateries and elegant fine-dining restaurants from all over the city.
Ristorante Fratelli Milano
Fratelli Milano has roots in Northern Italy with homemade pastries, pasta, and artisan bread.
The dessert menu is particularly noteworthy, featuring decadent options such as Nutella and cream-filled Italian donuts, sure to leave a lasting impression on diners.
People recommend ordering the Fiocchi Di Pera, Pappardelle Milano, Fettuccine Allo Scoglio, panna cotta, and tiramisu.
Menu: Fratelli Milano Menu
Top Review: “I came here late on a Saturday and they accommodated us with no problems, the service was quick and friendly. We ordered the pasta bolognese with steak and holy schmoly what is in that pasta because me and my friend were dying it was so good. We wanted more and more. The meat was tender flavorful pasta was fresh and did not cause any bloating whatsoever it was so nice!! I keep dreaming about it! I want more!! Lovely place. They also let us stay till the very very end. Did not kick us out even though it was way past closing time.” – Navene S.
Portosole
Portosole is the ultimate retreat for city dwellers looking to unwind with loved ones while savoring exquisite Italian cuisine.
They have excellent service with huge attention to detail. Visitors say the service really made them feel welcome and appreciated.
The food is as authentic as it gets, with well-loved dishes like Cacio E Pepe, Burrata, veal Milanese, and white truffle risotto.
The Italian spot is a little more expensive than others, but it’s better saved for special occasions.
Menu: Portosole Menu
Top Review: “Came for a friends birthday and it was amazing! The food was delicious and our waiter was very nice and helped with great suggestions. We shared everything between the 3 of us. The prosciutto and artichokes, the white truffle risotto, and the branzino were all amazing. And the show you get at your table with it just adds to the experience. It’s a bit pricey but worth it for special occasions.” – Teva V.
2530 Ponce De Leon Blvd Coral Gables, FL 33134, (786) 359-4275
Sapore di Mare
Sapore di Mare is designed to transport diners to the Amalfi Coast with its nautical-themed décor and colors.
The menu reflects the restaurant’s commitment to authenticity, featuring only high-quality ingredients sourced directly from Italy.
A must-try dish is the Cacio e Pepe, served in a wheel of pecorino cheese. Burrata and prosciutto, lobster ravioli, and lemon cake are other dishes to try.
Menu: Sapore di Mare Menu
Top Review: “THE BEST ITALIAN RESTAURANT IN MIAMI! Just come here and prove it for yourself! All the seafood is super fresh, pasta is perfectly done, staff super friendly and desserts decadent. Super worthy to give a try and enjoy delicious Italian food, try to make reservations since the place is very small” – Maria Alejandra O.
Contessa Miami
Contessa, one of the most exquisite Italian restaurants in America, made its debut in 2021 on the rooftop of The Newbury Boston in Boston. It quickly gained a reputation for being one of the most glamorous dining spots in the city.
Forbes described it as a place where customers would want to dress up and leave the sweatsuit behind.
In October 2022, Contessa expanded its reach and opened a new location in the Miami Design District.
The two-story space features marble floors, a grand staircase, and many lush design accents, which speak to the high fashion of the renowned neighborhood.
Menu: Contessa Menu
Top Review: “The service here is 10 out of 10. We loved Steven. Hands down phenomenal. All of his recommendations were on point. The dressing for the squash carpaccio was out of the world. They really need to bottle it and sell it. Also the lobster spaghetti was like crack. We loved it so much we had to order seconds. The ambiance is very intimate and classy. Perfect place for date night. Will definitely be back.” – Ella K.
Il Gabbiano
Il Gabbiano is one for the special occasions where you put on your Sunday best and celebrate good food and good company.
Il Gabbiano, a Miami institution, offers delicious dishes with incomparable flavor and traditional Italian cuisine. These are some of the best Italian food in Miami, and it’s worth a try for a special event.
Plus, they have these amazing views of Biscayne Bay and the city. Their popular dishes are bruschetta, lobster ravioli, and fried zucchini.
Menu: Il Gabbiano Menu
Top Review: “Talk about mouth watering food. Outstanding meal here the other night. Service is outstanding, servers are well trained, to provide while glove style service. We got a few bottles of wine and moet to start. Bruschetta and a piece of Parmesan is placed on your plate to start with a delicious bread basket for the table. Menu is in Italian for the most part, but the servers can answer any questions. I opted for the saltimbocca omg SO good. Those with me got sea bass, bolognese, lobster ravioli, and shrimp dishes all left very happy. The cheesecake for dessert was phenomenal and we even topped it off while limoncello. I will absolutely be back.” – Mariah B.
Fiola Miami
Fiola Miami is a spin-off of the Michelin-starred restaurant Fiola DC. It is considered one of the best Italian restaurants in Miami.
Their dishes come with a contemporary twist on their classic Italian food. The ambiance follows that theme with a perfect blend of comfort and elegance in this Italian spot.
Fiola’s best sellers include tiramisu, shell pasta cacio e pepe, cobia ceviche, and Ora King salmon.
Menu: Fiola Miami Menu
Top Review: “The rooftop at Fiola was such a cute perfect south Miami vibe. Watching the sunset over all the houses and trees was sooo cute!!! We came here on our team holiday dinner and we were all in love with this space. Let’s start off with I’m not a meat eater, but this filet mignon was cooked to perfection! It was so tender and juicy. The rigatoni was also very delicious (for being whole wheat!) The vibe and staff was very helpful and we had a great time here.” – Keysi J.
1500 San Ignacio Ave Coral Gables, FL 33146, (305) 912-2639
Dimitrios Mediterranean Cuisine & Pizza
In Miami, locals flock to Dimitrios Mediterranean Cuisine & Pizza for the best pizza in town. The restaurant has earned a reputation for excellence, and visitors should try their dishes to see why.
As a Slice partner for one year, Dimitrios Mediterranean Cuisine & Pizza is a beloved local business. Their curbside pickup option makes takeout a breeze. Customers can place an order, drive up, and enjoy their food.
Menu: Dimitrios Menu
Top Review: “One of the great locations to go in Brickell if you want to enjoy a great artisanal pizzas , pasta and table of extremely fresh Burrata with prosciutto or to eat one of the best meat balls with the recipe of la Nona! Also they have 3 different atmospheres inside, outside, and the terrace .. you can stay whatever you want they open 11:30 am to 11pm . The service is extremely good too. Ask for Dimitrios or Daniel they are very friendly, don’t forget to touch base here, the place is very good!” – Carolina A.
Amor di Pasta
Amor Di Pasta is owned and managed by an Italian family who specialize in traditional Italian pasta and pizza. Their menu features an array of mouth-watering dishes including seafood, gnocchi, and a separate menu with options. Amor di Pasta has a great cozy atmosphere that makes their guests feel like they are part of the family.
They use their mothers’ recipes to prepare the food, which makes the experience even more authentic. The owners have put in a lot of effort to make sure that the guests feel at home while dining at Amor Di Pasta.
The restaurant has many vegan and gluten-free options available for those with specific dietary needs.
Menu: Amor di Pasta Menu
Top Review: “This was a cute and quaint little spot in Miami which was away from all of the glitz and glamour Miami is known for. We ordered the pepperoni pizza which was hand tossed to its thinness and cooked perfectly. I relished the fact that it was so light it didn’t make me feel bloated. My friend and I also split lasagna which was equally light, yet filling. Our amazing server indulged us with their cappuccino tiramisu which was as guiltless tasting as the other dishes. Shout out to our server, who was a native to the region from which our dishes hailed, for providing exceptional service.” – Coya A.
Fratellino Ristorante
Join Beto DiCarlo at his latest restaurant venture, Fratellino in Coral Gables, for a taste of Italian fine dining. As a third-generation restaurateur, Beto brings his wealth of experience to create a warm and inviting atmosphere for his patrons.
Fratellino’s menu features traditional family recipes that have been passed down through generations. From the classic Caffe Ragazzi to Emilio’s Casa Toscana, Emilio’s Trattoria, and Betto’s, Beto has established himself as a renowned chef and restaurateur, and his latest establishment is no exception.
With its cozy and elegant ambiance, Fratellino is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner, family celebration, or a night out with friends. Reservations are strongly recommended to ensure a delightful dining experience.
Menu: Fratellino’s Menu
Top Review: “Another amazing date night at Fratellino! To my surprise Beto was not there. However, I am so pleased to say that the place ran just as smoothly! This speaks volumes of how well this establishment is managed. We did miss Beto’s infectious humor and as usual we will be back. No other place has our heart or keeps us coming back as much as Fratellino! Thank you so much for the wonderful dining experience and all the memories!” – Liliana G.
CRUST
CRUST is known for its unparalleled pizza and modern Italian cuisine, served in the scenic and rapidly trending area by the Miami River.
The restaurant boasts a unique dining experience, starting with its structure: a standalone Art Deco building built in the 1950s, which has retained its original charm with elegant geometric lines, striking Deco columns, and a lofty 14-foot ceiling. With a spacious 78-seat dining room and a lengthy 12-seat bar, customers can enjoy a comfortable and spacious dining experience.
CRUST’s pizza toppings are made with the freshest ingredients and offer tantalizing choices such as the Truffled Pizza with arugula, parmesan and truffle oil, the Mediterranean Pizza with feta cheese, kalamata olives, eggplant and fire roasted peppers, and their signature namesake Pizza with fig, prosciutto & blue cheese.
CRUST’s dedication to excellence has earned them numerous accolades, including OpenTable’s coveted 100 Best Restaurants in America for 2017 and 2019, and being voted one of the 25 pizzerias you need to visit in your lifetime by Yelp in 2019. With their unique dining experience and delicious cuisine, it’s no wonder that CRUST has gained such a reputation.
Menu: CRUST Menu
Top Review: “WE LOVEEEEE CRUST. My husband I decided to have Crust for our one year wedding anniversary with all of our friends, Anita the owner was soooooo accommodating to our party of 20!!! It truly was an amazing night. All of our friends and family left super satisfied with the food they loved everything! We always come back!” – Sarai R.
VERO Italian
Looking for the best Italian spots in Miami? Look no further than VERO Italian, a brand new venue located in the heart of downtown Miami.
With a commitment to authenticity, VERO Italian delivers delectable pizzas and pastas straight from their birthplace in Italy, without compromising on the traditional recipes that make Italian cuisine so beloved.
But it’s not just the food that sets VERO Italian apart – the location offers a unique urban setting that offers a tranquil oasis to unwind, taking the customer away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Miami to a special place that perfectly matches the spirit of their menu and outstanding service.
Menu: VERO Italian Menu
Top Review: “Such a cute, authentic spot in the neighborhood! When the waitress greeted us with a heavy Italian accent we automatically knew we were in for a treat. The food was all freshly prepared and incredibly tasty. The eggplant appetizer was a standout on its own. Tip: save the bread to dip in the sauce!” – Edna M.
Baiocco Osteria
Baiocco Osteria specializes in authentic and traditional food from Rome, Lazio Region, and Tuscany. The restaurant is in an old colonial house that has been restored to retain its historical architecture and create a sophisticated and vintage interior design.
It is located in the modern and suburban MiMo district, which is one of the trendiest areas in Miami. All staff members are Italian, which is a patriotic choice made to enhance the appeal of “made in Italy,” especially in terms of lifestyle and food, to American people and tourists from all over the world.
The menu features original Italian recipes. There are special dishes available to highlight regional cuisine, with a particular emphasis on the farming tradition of small areas in Central Italy, such as Sabina and Tuscia.
Menu: Baiocco Menu
Top Review: “Didn’t know what to expect when I first walked in. The exterior had a nice date vibe but the interior was a little country so I was immediately confused. However, the food and service were spectacular! One of the best Italian spots in South Florida by far. Definitely a hidden gem. Everything on the menu was amazing and will be back. Went there for a birthday party dinner and was one of the few places that could accommodate a group of 10+ people comfortably. If I could give it more than 5 stars I would.”
Red Carpet Italian Restaurant
Red Carpet Italian Restaurant, located in the heart of Downtown Miami, is a must-visit dining destination for those who crave a unique and unforgettable culinary experience.
As a local family-owned restaurant, Red Carpet takes pride in serving traditional Italian recipes, made from the finest selection of ingredients imported straight from Italy.
Customers can savor award-winning ravioli, homemade sauces, artisan cheeses, and an impressive wine list featuring boutique selections from small Italian producers, as well as blends unique to the United States.
Menu: Red Carpet Italian Menu
Top Review: “We have been coming here any time we are near Miami for over 4 years now. The food is always top notch. Nonna is often our server and she is so gracious and loving, I’m always excited to hear what she has made today. Tonight I got the meat lasagna, and it was absolutely divine! She also made a vanilla coconut cake which I couldn’t pass up, and while I was over stuffed from dinner, we couldn’t let it go to waste. The mojito chicken is my best friend’s favorite and he loved the profiteroles. Nonna makes the deserts (and can custom create for you if you order ahead). I am always so glad to see that they are surviving the difficult times during the pandemic. This place is special!” – Angela C.
Il Forno Ristorante
Menu:
Top Review:
Doma
Menu:
Top Review:
Coral House Miami
Menu:
Top Review:
Perricone’s Marketplace & Cafe
Menu:
Top Review:
Baccano
Menu:
Top Review:
Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar
Menu:
Top Review:
il Pastaiolo
Menu:
Top Review:
Borti
Menu:
Top Review:
Sylvano’s
Menu:
Top Review:
Miami is a foodie’s paradise with a wealth of fantastic Italian restaurants to choose from. We’ll let you decide which is the best Italian restaurant in Miami. But whether you’re in the mood for authentic regional dishes, traditional comfort food, or modern takes on classic Italian cuisine, there’s something for everyone. From the romantic waterside view at Il Gabbiano to the elegance of Fiola Miami, the city has no shortage of exceptional dining experiences.
You might also like drooling over these articles:
- The Best Italian Spots in New Jersey
- The Best Italian Restaurants in Kansas City
- Top Italian Restaurants in St. Louis, Missouri
- Top Italian Restaurants in Dallas
- The Best Italian Restaurants in Manhattan
- Pizza Paradise: The Best Pizza in Cincinnati
- The Top Pizza Restaurants in Boston
best italian miami, best italian miami, miami italian, Italian restaurants Miami, Best Italian restaurant Miami, Italian food Miami, Miami best Italian restaurants, Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar, Italian downtown Miami, Italian restaurants near me, Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar menu, Best Italian restaurants in South Miami, Fine Italian cuisine Miami, Mi’talia Kitchen and Bar Miami, Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar Miami FL, Mi’talia Miami, Mi Talia South Miami, Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar photos, Mi’talia Kitchen Miami, Mi Talia Miami, Mi’talia Kitchen & Bar Miami, Mi’talia South Miami, Mi Talia restaurant South Miami
