Italian cuisine is a staple in New Jersey, so wherever neighborhood you find yourself in, there’s sure to be an incredible restaurant near you.
Today, we’re rounding down the best Italian restaurants in New Jersey — from casual dining to upscale and elegant spots that are perfect for a date night. Get ready to indulge in pasta, pizza, and more Italian plates.
Di Paolo’s Italian Restaurant
Di Paolo’s is a great option to start your Italian food journey. It’s a cozy restaurant with a great ambiance, friendly service, and the occasional live music.
Their Italian cuisine is absolutely delicious that’s characterized by a seasonal menu alongside the classics.
Try their crab cakes, prime rib, or Italian wedding soup.
Menu: Di Paolo’s Menu
Top Review: “DELICIOUS! Plain and simple. I will definitely be back when I’m in the area. Our waitress Jewel was awesome and so patient. Everyone worked, was very sweet, the environment was nice and the ambiance was so nice! It’s mandatory I come back here and try the pasta dishes. The items we ordered are attached to this review. Trust me, GO HERE!” – Lisa H.
28 S Broad St Penns Grove, NJ 08069, (856) 299-4645
De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies
If you’re craving good pizza, head to De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies — one of the best Italian restaurants in New Jersey.
They are a classic go-to spot for a good pie, consistent quality, and generous portions. Pizzas have a charred thin crust with toppings like mushroom and broccoli, meatballs, and even clam pizza. Their antipasti are also popular — go for the heirloom tomato salad and seasonal salad.
For De Lorenzo’s, it’s best to go with their simple pizza: The plain tomato pie. It’s simple and straightforward, but it’s their bestseller for a reason.
Menu: De Lorenzo’s Menu
Top Review: “Arrived shortly after they opened and they were already super busy on a Saturday evening. From the recommendation of a friend, we had the tomato pie and a tomato pie with meatballs. I much preferred the tomato pie to the meatballs. They are well known for a phenomenal thin crust – which I loved. Because of the heaviness of the meatball, the crust wasn’t as crunchy as the plain. Would definitely return for a tomato pie with garlic and basil and a sausage, that looked great as well. Highly recommend if you are in the area :)” – Kristy C.
2350 US Hwy 33 Robbinsville, NJ 08691, (609) 341-8480
Villaggio Iccara
Villaggio Iccara is a mix of wood-fired pizza, pasta, seafood, and even subs. They are a family-owned restaurant that will treat you like a part of the family dinner.
It’s a huge place with outdoor seating, dining rooms, and a takeout section. They have a great selection of wine, but it’s also BYOB! People recommend pork chop, South Beach calamari, and spinach ravioli.
It’s an all-around solid choice for some of the best Italian dishes in New Jersey.
Menu: Villaggio Iccara Menu
Top Review: “I looooove coming here! Such a beautiful restaurant with delicious food. Pizza & cheesesteaks are great as well. The restaurant side is perfect for dinner date night and/or special occasions. Staff is always friendly. Not sure if the restaurant is byob since I’ve seen some diners bring their own alcohol but the menu offers a wine selection. The new outside patio is perfect for summer or early fall weather. Wish I live closer so I could come here more often but eat time I do it’s always a treat. Probably my favorite Italian restaurant ever!” – Jenny V.
104 Yardville Allentown Rd Hamilton, NJ 08620, (609) 585-7277
Travato’s Due
Menu: Travato’s Due Menu
Top Review: “Love it here! It’s my go to place with the family for Italian. We always get the escargot, gnocchi, and favorite dish veal saltimbocco. Service can sometimes be slow when they are busy but that’s just more family time and wine.” – Sean B.
4 Barbara Ln Oakland, NJ 07436, (201) 337-0813
Bottagra
Bottagra specializes in contemporary dishes using seasonal ingredients. It’s the place to go when you’re in Northern New Jersey.
It’s a no-frills spot with a simple menu that people consistently return to. If you’re also looking for some fun, they have themed dinner parties here every Thursday with music and sometimes even some dancing.
Try their black squid ink pasta, filet mignon, or spinach malfatti.
Menu: Bottagra Menu
Top Review: “I came on a Thursday night and was not expecting to be at one of the greatest parties in New Jersey! First off, the food was amazing. Very responsible of us before the party started… Then it starts. Nonstop beats, great host, neverending entertainment. It’s a fun time! The restaurant and team did such a great job. You best believe I’m coming back!” – Ina M.
80 Wagaraw Rd Hawthorne, NJ 07506, (973) 423-4433
Il Capriccio Ristorante
Il Capriccio is an upscale dining experience still with a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere.
It’s the epitome of the Italian restaurant vibe — a live pianist, dim, romantic lighting, and plush chairs.
They’re known for their extensive wine selection and really know their stuff. Recommendations include Chilean sea bass, beef short rib, and veal chop.
It’s a little more expensive, but the experience is worth it.
Top Review: “We had a perfect dining experience with our server Gianni! He knew the menu inside and out and was very personable, enhancing our night. The setting is elegant, starting with a cocktail in the lounge then moving into the dining area for a delicious meal. The Caesar salad which is made table side is not to be missed! The menu has something for everyone, the presentation is a 10 out of 10. Everyone there is very welcoming and attentive. We will definitely return to enjoy more of the menu!” – Cindy J.
633 Rte 10 E Whippany, NJ 07981, (973) 884-9175
New Jersey is a massive place with so much Italian food to offer. They know how to do Italian cuisine well, which shows in their various restaurants. Whether you’re looking for pasta or pizza, something casual or elegant, contemporary or classic, there’s something for everyone. So order a glass of wine and enjoy the food!
You might also like drooling over these articles:
- The Best Italian Restaurants in Kansas City
- Top Italian Restaurants in St. Louis, Missouri
- Top Italian Restaurants in Dallas
- The Best Italian Restaurants in Manhattan
- Pizza Paradise: The Best Pizza in Cincinnati
- The Top Pizza Restaurants in Boston
best italian new jersey, best italian new jersey, new jersey italian
